GPS and Alcohol Monitoring: Who Decides What Happens After an Alert?


A GPS device reports a possible boundary violation. An alcohol monitor records a concerning result. A client misses a required breath test.
What happens next?
The answer depends on the court’s instructions, the information available, and the authority given to the monitoring provider. Reviewing an alert, reporting possible noncompliance, and deciding what court action should follow are separate responsibilities.
At JSG Monitoring, we help courts and agencies develop GPS and alcohol monitoring programs with clear procedures, reporting expectations, and responsibilities. Understanding what happens after an alert is an essential part of that work.
Do electronic monitoring providers have discretion when responding to violations?
Sometimes. The provider’s discretion depends on the authority granted for that case or program.
Some courts allow providers to exercise judgment within established guidelines, considering an alert’s severity and the surrounding circumstances. Other courts require a prescribed response and give the provider no discretion to depart from it.
The same type of event may therefore receive different responses under different court instructions, even when the monitoring provider is the same.
Clients should understand that an explanation does not necessarily remove the provider’s obligation to report an event. Courts should clearly document where discretion exists and where it does not.
Authority to exercise judgment when responding to an alert also does not automatically include permission to change someone’s court conditions.
Does an electronic monitoring alert automatically establish a violation?
An automated alert, a provider’s review, and a court’s determination are different parts of the process.
An alert identifies something requiring attention. Understanding what happened may involve reviewing device records, approved schedules, communication history, and the applicable court conditions.
For example, federal court guidance recognizes that GPS drift can produce questionable location points that require investigation. A location point should be evaluated alongside the surrounding data.
Review does not suspend required reporting or response procedures. When notification is required before the review is complete, the provider should explain what is known, what remains under review, and communicate the findings afterward.
Does continuous alcohol monitoring show whether someone is impaired right now?
Continuous alcohol monitoring should not be treated as an immediate measurement of current impairment.
A transdermal device such as SCRAM CAM measures alcohol released through the skin. As SCRAM Systems explains, those readings lag behind breath alcohol measurements. Transdermal readings are not interchangeable with blood or breath alcohol levels.
There is also a difference between collecting information, transmitting it, and reviewing it. SCRAM CAM collects readings throughout the day, while its base station transfers stored information on a configured schedule, as described in the SCRAM CAM user guide.
Courts should understand these distinctions when selecting alcohol monitoring and establishing notification expectations.
Is a missed alcohol test the same as a positive alcohol test?
They establish different facts, even when a court requires a similar response.
A positive breath test records an alcohol result from a submitted sample. A missed test generally means the required test was not completed within the assigned testing window.
A missing result also requires careful review. Some devices can store completed tests when cellular service is unavailable and transmit them later. The review should distinguish a failure to test from a completed test whose transmission was delayed.
A missed test may itself violate the court’s requirements, but it should not be described as a measured alcohol result. A later negative test also does not automatically resolve an earlier missed test. The provider must follow the applicable instructions for both events.
Does GPS monitoring guarantee that a victim will receive warning before someone approaches?
No. GPS monitoring can support victim safety, but it cannot guarantee advance warning or prevent physical contact.
Notifications depend on the system, its configuration, functioning equipment, connectivity, and other conditions. Wearing a GPS device does not automatically mean a victim notification service is active.
Victims should receive a clear explanation of which notifications are available, who responds, and what to do if a threat occurs without an alert.
A safety plan must remain useful when technology is unavailable. In immediate danger, call 911 rather than wait for a monitoring notification.
What should courts expect when monitoring results are disputed?
A clear explanation of the evidence, the review, and the response.
A useful report distinguishes device records, client statements, staff observations, and conclusions. Information supporting the client’s explanation deserves consideration alongside information suggesting noncompliance.
The report should identify unresolved questions or limitations and explain what action the provider took. It should also make clear whether that action followed a mandatory instruction or an authorized exercise of discretion.
What should courts ask about a provider’s response procedures?
Courts should know who receives each type of alert, who reviews the supporting information, and which events require immediate escalation.
Those expectations should address nights, weekends, and holidays, including what happens if the designated contact cannot be reached. The program should identify who documents the response, how findings reach the court, and who has authority to act.
These questions should be addressed before the device is installed.
Clear expectations make monitoring programs stronger
At JSG Monitoring, we help courts and agencies turn monitoring requirements into practical program procedures. That includes defining responsibilities, establishing reporting expectations, and explaining what the selected technology can and cannot establish.
Courts should know how their instructions will be carried out. Clients should understand their obligations. Victims should understand the notifications available to them and the limitations of the technology.
Contact JSG Monitoring to discuss your GPS and alcohol monitoring program, including alert review, reporting requirements, and response procedures.
__________________________________________________________________________________
About the Writer
John Hays is President of JSG Monitoring and has extensive experience in electronic monitoring, court services, and community supervision. He works with courts, law enforcement agencies, supervision professionals, and monitoring providers to develop practical electronic monitoring programs focused on accountability, public safety, and reliable decision making.



